Looking for a Halloween game that doesn’t feel like it’s just for little kids?
This post may contain affiliate links.
Halloween Would You Rather is an easy game to pull out at a party, around a bonfire, during a Halloween movie night, or while everyone is hanging out after trick-or-treating.
There are no right or wrong answers. Just choose one, defend your choice if you want to, and see what everyone else picks!
Funny Halloween Would You Rather Questions
- Would you rather have a pumpkin for a head or bat wings for arms?
- Would you rather accidentally walk into a giant spiderweb or step into a puddle of fake blood?
- Would you rather have a witch’s laugh or a vampire’s fangs?
- Would you rather have a black cat follow you everywhere or a ghost follow you everywhere?
- Would you rather wear a costume that is three sizes too big or three sizes too small?
Spooky Halloween Would You Rather Questions
- Would you rather spend the night in a haunted house or an abandoned castle?
- Would you rather hear mysterious footsteps behind you or strange noises coming from the attic?
- Would you rather be followed by a friendly ghost or a mischievous vampire?
- Would you rather walk through a dark forest alone or explore an old abandoned house?
- Would you rather spend Halloween with a skeleton or a werewolf?
Halloween Candy Would You Rather Questions
- Would you rather have unlimited chocolate or unlimited gummy candy?
- Would you rather give up chocolate for a year or candy for a year?
- Would you rather have one enormous candy bar or an entire bag of your favorite candy?
- Would you rather eat only candy corn or only chocolate for Halloween?
- Would you rather trade half of your Halloween candy for a mystery bag or keep everything you collected?
Halloween Costume Would You Rather Questions
- Would you rather dress as a vampire or a witch?
- Would you rather wear a really scary costume or a completely ridiculous costume?
- Would you rather have a costume that glows in the dark or one that makes spooky sounds?
- Would you rather wear the same costume every Halloween or come up with a completely different costume every year?
- Would you rather wear a costume everyone recognizes or one nobody has ever seen before?
Halloween Party Would You Rather Questions
- Would you rather go trick-or-treating or stay home and hand out candy?
- Would you rather win a Halloween costume contest or a Halloween game tournament?
- Would you rather go to a huge Halloween party or have a small Halloween gathering with your favorite people?
- Would you rather spend Halloween playing trivia or watching scary movies?
- Would you rather have Halloween last for an entire week or celebrate Halloween twice a year?
How to Play Halloween Would You Rather
The great thing about this game is that you don’t really need anything to play.
Simply read a question out loud and have everyone choose their answer.
For a group, you can have everyone move to one side of the room or the other depending on their choice. You can also have people raise their hands or vote.
And don’t stop at the answer!
Some of the funniest conversations happen when someone has to explain why they picked their answer.
This works especially well for:
- Halloween parties
- Teen gatherings
- Adult Halloween parties
- Family game nights
- Bonfires
- Halloween movie nights
- Classroom or youth group activities
- Getting-to-know-you games
Make Halloween Would You Rather Even Easier
If you don’t want to come up with questions while you’re trying to host a party, a printable game makes it easy to have everything ready to go.
Halloween Would You Rather Game
Print the questions, cut them apart if you’d like, and put them in a bowl for guests to draw throughout the evening. You can also simply keep the printable handy and take turns reading the questions.
Whether you’re hosting a big Halloween party or just looking for something fun to do with friends, these questions are an easy way to get everyone talking and laughing.
I’ve put together several Halloween games that are ready to print and play.
Ready-to-Print Halloween Games
- Halloween Would You Rather Game
- Halloween Scavenger Hunt
- Halloween Scavenger Hunt Riddles
- Halloween Minute to Win It Games
- Halloween Charades
- Halloween Scary Movie Trivia
More Halloween Games to Try
- 20 Halloween Minute to Win It Games for Teens and Adults
- 10 Halloween Party Games Everyone Will Want to Play
- 15 Halloween Scavenger Hunt Ideas for Kids
- 25 Halloween Would You Rather Questions for Kids
Follow my Halloween Games & Activities board on Pinterest.
